JPMC Workers Alliance Logo

Myth Busting: Common Claims and the Facts

Myth Busting: Common Claims and the Facts

By BK

Below is a short, plain-language collection of common myths about unions and concise facts.


Myth: The union is a third party that will come between us

Fact: You and your coworkers are the union. It’s a democratic organization of employees that negotiates enforceable rules with management — not a third-party that replaces your voice. Why it matters: A union empowers collective decision-making and enforcement of workplace rules, which protects everyone from arbitrary actions.


Myth: Management isn’t anti-union — a union just isn’t right here

Fact: When campaigns start, employers commonly use captive meetings and consultants to dissuade workers. Neutral employers don’t spend resources on anti-union campaigns.


Myth: Unions are outdated in today’s economy

Fact: Unions are actively organizing in modern sectors (tech, logistics, retail, higher education) because they address current problems like surveillance, remote work rights, and pay equity.


Myth: Bargaining starts from zero — you could lose what you have

Fact: First contracts typically start from current wages and benefits. Any contract must be ratified by workers before it takes effect. Retaliatory cuts are illegal.


Myth: Unions just want your dues

Fact: Dues are set democratically by members and fund bargaining, legal support, safety, and strike benefits. Many workers see net financial gains from union representation.


Myth: Union leaders are outsiders or corrupt, and they’ll force strikes

Fact: Unions are member‑run with elections and financial reporting. Strikes require a democratic vote and are uncommon; employers more often stall bargaining than unions force conflict.


Myth: If you unionize, the company will close or move

Fact: Threatening to close or move in order to stop union activity can be illegal. Many unionization-related closures have prompted NLRB cases; profitable, unionized companies are common.


Myth: Union organizers are lying; look at these bad actors

Fact: Employers often point to isolated scandals while ignoring systemic unlawful conduct like firings, threats, and captive meetings. Federal oversight and reporting requirements apply to unions.


Myth: If a union comes in, you’ll be forced to go on strike

Fact: No one can be forced to strike. Strikes are decided by members and are used as a last resort. Having the option to strike improves bargaining leverage.


Myth: If we unionize, everyone will be forced to join and pay dues

Fact: Closed shops were outlawed in 1947. In most places membership is voluntary; in some states (“right-to-work”) you may not even be required to pay fees.


Myth: Unions protect lazy workers and hold back high performers

Fact: Unions promote fair, transparent processes for discipline (such as “just cause”). Poor performers can still be addressed under those rules; unions reduce favoritism and reward experience.


Myth: Unions cause conflict and a hostile work environment

Fact: A union creates structured, peaceful ways to resolve disputes. Most hostility around organizing comes from employer anti‑union tactics, not union activity.

Sources and links within are provided inline. For corrections or suggestions, please send us an email or let us know on discord.